These two literary heroines both have a special place in my bookworm heart. Bella because she's clumsy like me (though thankfully I'm not that accident prone), and because she becomes an amazing vampire. Katniss because she has to go through some terrible, shocking ordeals in her life, and most of it for the entertainment of others or being used by others.
I have nothing against Bella... but I have to say Katniss. Not only because I prefer The Hunger Games over Twilight but I think the Katniss is a more complex and intricate character. For example; when reading the books I found myself surprised at some of the decisions she made.. whereas that never happened in Twilight.
ImmortalWolfehFeatured By OwnerSep 19, 2012Hobbyist Traditional Artist
okay, by reading the comments, i've learned that some people are stupid for wanting to pick a girl who chose to be a vampire because of her boyfriend and was just stupid enough to fight werewolves!! bella is stupid.
Katniss. I find Bella... well... weak? I have a thing for strong female leads... and mostly I don't even like I-narrator's I tried to read Twilight but I just couldn't finish the third chapter... I am currently mid-Catching Fire and I am hooked... so... No offence to those who like Bella...
This is a hard one. I prefer Katniss becuase she is more depndalbe on herself and less like a Damsle in Distress 24/7, However I prefer Bella because she has more emotion than Katniss. Sometimes Katniss was just too much and needed to stop and think before doing something. I cant choose Ill have to say both.
I don't care what other people think. I prefer Bella, b/c although she's kinda clumsy and weak, I love her emotions and reactions. I personally don't care for Katniss, simply b/c girls weren't made to fight for the death, I think that's stupid to be honest.. and yeah my friend got me interested in the twilight books, so after I saw the first movie, I read the books b/c they r actually good. I saw Hunger Games, but there was no real motivation of interest in it for me, and so strong girls who fight aren't really that appealing. And, by the way, Bella did a good job in the new movie, "Snow White and the huntsmen" So, it's Bella. And in a lot of ways, she's like me: long dark hair, loves reading, isn't ashamed of her relationship, even though Edward is a strange guy, I think it's cute. So yeah, sorry for the extremely long comment, but I just had to. c:
This is sort of the same comment I made on the Edward or Peeta comment, but: I read both series and to be honest I don't think you can compare the two... I mean you can on one hand, but then on the other they are two totally different stories. There are things about Bella that bug me or really bug me and there are things about Katniss that bug me and on two occasions really bug me, but then I love certain qualities of both. I think they are both strong, independent women who really mature in different ways, and because of this I love them both and think they are both great characters. A for those who didn't read the books (or seen the movies) I won't spoil it, but I am very happy with how each of the series ended, they ended the way I wanted them too so that probably helps why I like them too.
I like both. The problem with Bella is, she was a damsewl in distress before she was turned afterwards she became badass & Katniss was overly awesome in the 1st book but her strange seemed to lowing in the next 2 books, like she wasn't that smart anymore. So I like Bella because she growed up & Katniss because she's overly powerful & won a war, but as I said she lost something...